Explanation: Government Censorship
Explanation: Government Censorship
Date | Action | Agency | Explanation | Scientists Affected | Summary | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2019-10-03 | White House Strikes Climate Change Language from Vehicle Emissions Proposal | Federal, White House | Government Censorship | Climate | The White House deleted references to climate change from a proposal limiting California’s ability to set stricter vehicle emissions standards. |
|
2019-08-21 | Federal Officials Suppress Report Detailing Risk to Fish Species from Trump Administration’s California Irrigation Plan | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Other | Federal officials suppressed report detailing how Trump administration plan to divert water for agriculture in California would risk the state’s salmon runs. |
|
2019-08-07 | U.S. Navy Shuts Task Force on Climate Change | DOD, Federal | Government Censorship, Personnel Changes | The U.S. Navy has quietly shut down its Task Force on Climate Change |
||
2019-07-22 | DOI Removes References to Climate Change from WaterSMART Program Webpage | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | EDGI report shows that DOI removed all reference to climate change from its WaterSMART program web page. |
|
2019-07-22 | USFS Removes References to Climate Change from Wilderness Webpage | Federal, USDA | Government Censorship | Climate | EDGI report shows that USFS removed references to climate change from its webpage about wilderness areas. |
|
2019-07-22 | USGCRP Removes Sections on Climate Change from its Website | Federal, USGCRP | Government Censorship | Climate | EDGI report shows that USGCRP removed sections about climate change from its website |
|
2019-07-22 | EPA’s Website Reclassifies Research Groups to Remove Climate Change Group | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | EDGI report shows that the EPA reclassified its research categories on its website to remove the climate change group. |
|
2019-07-22 | DOE Removes References to Climate Change from Biological and Environmental Research Group Webpages | DOE, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | EDGI report shows that the DOE removed references to climate change from its BER group webpages |
|
2019-07-22 | EPA Removes Climate Change References from “Heat Island Effect” Webpage | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | EDGI report shows that EPA changed its website to downplay the impact of climate change on the heat island effect. |
|
2019-07-22 | OSHA Removes References to Climate Change from Page About Heat-Related Illnesses | DOL, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | EDGI report shows that OSHA removed references to the impact of climate change from its page on heat related illnesses in the workplace |
|
2019-07-22 | USGS Removes Climate Change Links and Page from its Website | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | EDGI report shows that the USGS removed all links and references to climate change from its Science Explorer section |
|
2019-07-18 | USDA Officials Buried Climate Change Response Plan | Federal, USDA | Government Censorship | Climate, Other | The USDA buried a plan detailing how agriculture can adapt to climate change |
|
2019-07-08 | USGS Removes References to Climate Change from Press Release | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate, Other | USGS revised a researcher-written news release on a study of the California coastline to omit all reference to the impact of climate change on the coastline |
|
2019-06-24 | USDA Buries Studies that Show Damages from Climate Change | Federal, USDA | Government Censorship | Climate, Other | Scientists at the USDA claim that the agency has deliberately failed to publicize research publications that address the impact of climate change |
|
2019-06 | State Department Scientist Prevented from Submitting Written Testimony to Congress | Federal, State Department, White House | Government Censorship | Climate | White House officials ordered a senior scientist at the U.S. Department of State not to submit written testimony on the threats posed by climate change to the House Intelligence Committee. |
|
2019-05-27 | USGS Scientists Ordered Not to Model Long-Term Climate Impacts | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship, Research Hindrance | Climate | Scientists at the U.S. Geological Survey were directed to use computer-generated models that only project climate change impacts through 2040. The scientists had previously modeled climate change impacts through 2100, which experts say provides a more accurate picture of climate change because the effects of current greenhouse gas emissions will primarily be felt after 2040. |
|
2019-05-13 | Massachusetts Restricting State Scientists’ Communications | MA, State | Government Censorship | Other | Under the current Governor of Massachusetts, state scientists are required to obtain permission from state public relations officials before speaking with journalists; however, a recent story in the Boston Globe revealed that interview requests by the media have been routinely denied. |
|
2019-03 | References to “Climate Change” Removed from EPA Document | EPA, Federal, White House | Government Censorship | Climate | The White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs deleted several references to “climate change” from an EPA guidance document titled “Planning for Natural Disaster Debris.” The deleted references highlighted the link between climate change and extreme weather events. |
|
2019-02 | NASA Pressured to Remove Climate Change Information from Website | Federal, NASA | Government Censorship | Climate | A member of the Trump administration’s National Security Council, William Happer, emailed the deputy administrator of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration, James Morehard, to complain about the inclusion of climate change information on its website. |
|
2019-01-16 | Release of NOAA Disaster-Cost Estimate Delayed | DOC, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | Due to the partial government shutdown, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration has delayed release of its annual disaster-cost estimate, showing the total cost of weather and climate-related disasters in 2018. |
|
2019-01-15 | Release of NOAA / NASA Temperature Data Delayed | DOC, Federal, NASA | Government Censorship | Climate | The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and National Aeronautics and Space Administration have been forced to delay release of the annual global temperature analysis for 2018 due to the partial government shutdown. |
|
2019-01-12 | USDA Scientists Prevented from Attending Scientific Conference | Federal, USDA | Government Censorship | Other | Hundreds of scientists from the U.S. Department of Agriculture were prevented from attending the 27th Annual Plant and Genome Conference due to the partial government shutdown. |
|
2019-01-10 | NASA Scientists Prevented from Attending Conference | Federal, NASA | Government Censorship | Other | Federal government scientists, from the National Aeronautics and Space Administration and other agencies, were prevented from attending the annual meeting of the American Astronomical Society due to the partial government shutdown. |
|
2019-01-07 | DOE Scientists Prevented from Traveling to Conferences | DOE, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate, Other | DOE officials ordered staff in the Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy to cancel all travel scheduled through the end of February 2019. The officials cited the partial government shutdown as the reason for requiring travel to be cancelled. However, DOE is not affected by the shutdown, having been fully-funded through the 2019 fiscal year. |
|
2019-01-03 | NOAA Scientists Prevented from Attending Scientific Conference | DOC, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | Scientists at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) were told they would “not be able to participate” in the annual meeting of the American Meterological Society (AMS) due to the partial government shutdown which forced the cancellation of “all official NOAA travel to the AMS.” |
|
2019-01 | Access to NOAA Climate Change Website Blocked | DOC, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | Due to the partial government shutdown, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration blocked access to its National Climatic Data Center website, which includes multiple climate data sets. |
|
2019-01 | Scientific Conference Cancelled by USDA Due to Partial Government Shutdown | Federal, USDA | Government Censorship, Research Hindrance | Climate, Other | Citing the partial federal government shutdown, the U.S. Department of Agriculture cancelled its 30th annual Research Forum on Invasive Species, which had been scheduled to take place from January 8 to 11. According to USDA officials, the forum will not be rescheduled during 2019, due to difficulties “coordinating with speakers and the hotel.” |
|
2018-12-22 | Access to BLM Conservation Website Blocked During Government Shutdown | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate, Other | Citing the government shutdown, the DOI’s Bureau of Land Management blocked access to a website, containing links to documents discussing proposed changes to the conservation rules for greater sage grouse habitat. The block, which appears to violate DOI guidance, was implemented despite the fact that DOI is currently accepting comments on the proposed rule changes. |
|
2018-12-04 | Climate Change Report Removed from Alaska DEC Website | AK, State | Government Censorship | Climate | In December 2018, one day after new Alaska Governor Mike Dunleavy took office, the state Department of Environmental Conservation deleted a key climate change report from its website. The report, titled “Climate Change Policy Recommendations to the Governor,” included a detailed plan for addressing climate change impacts in Alaska. |
|
2018-11-21 | EPA Staff Prevented from Updating Climate Change Indicators Website | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship, Self-Censorship | Climate | EPA staff have been prevented from updating an agency website, titled “Climate Change Indicators in the United States,” which is intended to “compile a key set of indicators related to the causes and effects of climate change.” During the Obama Administration, new indicators were added to the website every six months, but no updates have been made since President Trump took office. |
|
2018-11 | Climate Change Omitted from Oceans Research Plan | Federal, White House | Government Censorship, Research Hindrance | Climate | The White House published a new report, titled “Science and Technology for America’s Oceans,” identifying research priorities for oceans science and technology. The report omits a section discussing research priorities with respect to “the ocean’s role in climate,” which had appeared in all previous versions of the report. |
|
2018-10-24 | Climate Change Omitted from List of EPA Research Objectives | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship, Research Hindrance | Climate | EPA published a draft “Air and Energy Strategic Research Action Plan” identifying research needed to address its “strategic objectives and mandates to improve air quality.” Unlike previous versions adopted during the Obama administration, the Action Plan does not list climate change preparation as a “research objective.” |
|
2018-10-03 | Climate Change Materials Removed from DOT Website | DOT, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | The Department of Transportation (DOT) removed at least two pages discussing climate change from its website. One of the pages had previously served as DOT’s “Transportation and Climate Change Clearinghouse,” providing a “one-stop source of information on transportation and climate change issues. The second page had included links to studied on the impacts of climate change on the transportation sector. |
|
2018-10-02 | References to “Climate Change” Removed from EPA Document | EPA, Federal, White House | Government Censorship | Climate | The White House Office of Management and Budget removed several paragraphs discussing climate change and its impact on human health from a proposed EPA rule. The removed paragraphs emphasized the particular vulnerability of “children, the elderly, and the poor . . . to climate-related health effects.” |
|
2018-09-18 | Climate Change Omitted from National Biodefense Strategy | Federal, White House | Government Censorship | Climate | The White House published a new National Biodefense Strategy, outlining measures to prevent and mitigate disease outbreaks. Despite numerous scientific studies finding that climate change will increase the risk of such outbreaks, it is not discussed anywhere in the strategy. |
|
2018-09-10 | References to “Climate Change” Removed from NPS Report | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship, Self-Censorship | Climate | A draft planning document, developed for the New Bedford Whaling Historical Park, was edited to remove all references to “climate change.” The edits were made after officials in the National Park Service’s Northeast Regional Office warned park employees that “we’re being told . . . [to] avoid” discussion of future climate impacts. |
|
2018-09-09 | Scientific Data and Records to be Destroyed by DOI | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship, Research Hindrance | Other | DOI filed a “Request for Records Disposition Authority” with the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA). In the request, DOI seeks permission from NARA to destroy records relating to its conservation, land use, energy, and water programs. Many of the records document the findings of scientific research or contain data needed to conduct such research. |
|
2018-09-05 | References to “Climate Change” Removed from EPA Regulatory Impact Analysis | EPA, Federal, White House | Government Censorship | Climate | The White House Office of Management and Budget removed several paragraphs discussing climate change and its impact on human health from EPA’s regulatory impact analysis on the proposed Affordable Clean Energy Rule. |
|
2018-09 | References to “Climate Change” Removed from Report of Vermont Natural Resources Board | State, VT | Government Censorship | Climate | The Vermont Governor’s office removed several references to “climate change” from a report, prepared by the state Natural Resources Board, exploring changes to the state’s land use permitting process. |
|
2018-08-14 | Public Communication by NPS Scientists Restricted | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate, Other | A survey of scientists at DOI’s National Park Service found various restrictions on their ability to communicate with the public and journalists. |
|
2018-08-14 | FWS Scientists Prevented from Discussing or Researching “Politically Contentious” Topics | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship, Research Hindrance | Climate, Other | A survey of scientists at DOI’s Fish and Wildlife Service found that many have been told not to work on topics deemed “politically contentious” and to omit “politically contentious” words, including “climate change” and “science,” from their reports. |
|
2018-07-31 | Climate Change Omitted from List of White House R&D Priorities | Federal, White House | Budget Cuts, Government Censorship, Research Hindrance | Climate | The White House Office of Management and Budget and Office of Science and Technology Policy jointly released a memorandum outlining the Trump administration’s research and development priorities. Unlike previous versions, issued during the Obama administration, the memorandum does not list climate change as a priority area. |
|
2018-07-24 | References to “Climate Change” Removed from USAID Report | Federal, USAID | Government Censorship | Climate | References to “climate change” were removed from the U.S. Agency for International Development’s 2017 Sustainability Report. In a departure from previous versions, the 2017 report no longer lists “climate change adaptation” as a priority, and omits a section discussing “proposed actions” to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. |
|
2018-07-17 | Impacts of Climate Change Downplayed by FEMA | DHS, Federal | Bias and Misrepresentation, Government Censorship | Climate | The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) did not discuss climate change in its After Action Report on the 2017 hurricane season. Speaking about the report, FEMA’s Deputy Administrator for Resilience appeared to suggest that climate change is a natural phenomenon, stating “the climate shifts, it changes over time.” |
|
2018-07-06 | Release of Health Study Blocked by EPA | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship | Other | Senior EPA officials reported sought to block release of a scientific study discussing the health hazards posed by formaldehyde. |
|
2018-07-02 | References to “Climate Change” Removed from Treasury Department Report | Federal, Treasury Department | Government Censorship | Climate | References to “climate change” were removed from the Department of the Treasury’s 2017 Sustainability Report. In a departure from previous versions, the 2017 report no longer lists “climate change resilience” as a goal of the department, and omits discussion of programs aimed at addressing climate change risks. |
|
2018-06-21 | Public Communication by USGS Scientists Restricted | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate, Other | DOI issued a new media protocol that requires scientists at the U.S. Geological Survey to obtain approval before speaking to journalists. The protocol permits DOI to reject interview requests on scientific matters. |
|
2018-06-14 | New Conference Approval Process Adopted by USGS | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate, Other | The U.S. Geological Survey, within the Department of the Interior, will require scientists wishing to attend certain conferences to provide their presentation title(s) and an explanation of how their research relates to the priorities of Interior Secretary Zinke. The information will be reviewed by a political appointee, who will determine which scientists can attend each conference. |
|
2018-06 | Release of Chemical Assessments Blocked by EPA | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship | Other | EPA officials ordered staff in the Integrated Risk Information System (IRIS) program not to release human health toxicity assessments prepared for chemicals. Staff were told they could only release chemical assessments that had been specifically requested by the leadership of an EPA program office. Program office leaders were subsequently told to limit their assessment requests to “no more than three to four chemicals.” |
|
2018-05-14 | Release of Scientific Study Blocked | EPA, Federal, HHS, White House | Government Censorship | Other | White House and EPA officials sought to block publication of HHS study on the health effects of water contamination due to concerns that it would be a “public relations nightmare.” |
|
2018-05-10 | References to “Climate Change” Removed from DOD Report | DOD, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | A DOD report discussing how climate change is affecting military bases was edited to remove several references to “climate change” and downplay its impacts. For example, several references to climate change-induced sea level rise and its impact on military bases were removed, as were references to declines in Arctic sea ice. |
|
2018-05-03 | DOI Staff Prevented from Attending Scientific Conference | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Other | DOI’s Bureau of Land Management prevented at least 14 scientists from attending the annual meeting of the Society for American Archaeology. Several of those prevented from attending had been scheduled to speak at a symposium, which had to be cancelled due to the lack of participation by government scientists. |
|
2018-05 | Discussion of Climate Change Omitted from Florida Governor’s Hurricane Conference | FL, State | Government Censorship | Climate | Florida Governor Rick Scott hosted the Governor’s Hurricane Conference, which is intended to provide information on how to prepare for and recover from hurricanes. None of the conference sessions discussed on climate change or sea level rise, despite significant scientific evidence that those phenomena will increase hurricane severity. |
|
2018-04-23 | Release of Federal Sustainability Reports Delayed | Federal, White House | Government Censorship | Climate | The White House Office of Management and Budget has delayed the release of sustainability reports prepared by at least seven federal agencies under Executive Order 13693 (signed by President Obama in March 2015). |
|
2018-04-02 | References to Humans’ Role in Climate Change Removed from NPS Report | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship, Self-Censorship | Climate | Officials at the National Parks Service edited a report on the impact of sea level rise and flooding on coastal national parks to remove all references to humans’ role in causing climate change. |
|
2018-03-28 | EPA Talking Points Misrepresent Climate Science | EPA, Federal | Bias and Misrepresentation, Government Censorship | Climate | EPA’s Office of Public Affairs issued a set of approved talking points on climate change. The talking points appear to be intended to cast doubt on the scientific consensus on climate change, with one stating “[w]hile there has been extensive research . . . clear gaps remain,” including in “our understanding of the role of human activity” in contributing to climate change. |
|
2018-03-15 | References “Climate Change” Removed from FEMA Documents | DHS, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) published a new strategic plan in which all references to “climate change” and “global warming” have been removed. |
|
2018-03-09 | EPA Staff Participation in Scientific Integrity Survey Restricted | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate, Other | EPA scientists were warned against participating in a survey on scientific integrity within the federal government. An email containing a link to the survey was classified as spam “stemming from an unknown entity” by EPA’s Computer Security Incident Response Center, despite those running the survey providing advance notice to that it would be sent. |
|
2018-01-31 | Milwaukee Health Department Employees Prevented from Discussing Lead Contamination | Local Govt., State, WI | Government Censorship | Other | Former Milwaukee Health Commissioner Bevan Baker ordered Health Department employees not to discuss concerns about lead contamination with members of the city council. |
|
2018-01-20 | NOAA Climate Change Website Suspended During Government Shutdown | DOC, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | During the government shutdown, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration temporarily suspended access to a website providing climate change data, while continuing to allow access to several other sites. The climate change website returned to service on January 23, 2018, following the end of the government shutdown. |
|
2018-01-17 | NIEHS Director’s Involvement in Scientific Study Investigated | Congress, Federal | Government Censorship, Research Hindrance | Other | The House Committee on Science, Space, and Technology announced it was reviewing the involvement of Dr. Linda Birnbaum, the director of the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, in a study of federal toxics regulation and requested that HHS also commence a review. |
|
2018 | References to “Climate Change” Removed from Amtrak Strategic Plan | Amtrak, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | Amtrak published a new five strategic plan, which omitted any reference to climate change. Previous versions of the plan had listed “environment / climate change” as the number one threat to Amtrak’s system. |
|
2017-12-20 | Climate Change Documents Removed from NPS Website | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | Documents describing the climate action plans of 92 national parks were removed from the National Park Service website. |
|
2017-12-14 | CDC Staff Given List of Forbidden Words | Federal, HHS | Government Censorship | Other | Policy analysts at the Centers for Disease Control were given a list of 7 words, including “evidence-based” and “science-based,” which should not be used in documents prepared for next year’s budget. |
|
2017-12-13 | References to “Climate Change” Removed from FHWA Program | DOT, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | The Federal Highway Administration’s “Sustainable Transport and Climate Change” program was renamed the “Sustainable Transportation and Resilience” program and several references to climate change were removed from its website. |
|
2017-12 | DOI Scientists Prevented from Attending Conference | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | DOI capped the number of staff who could attend the American Geophysical Union’s annual meeting at 199 (down from 450 in previous years). |
|
2017-12 | Florida Officials Barred from Referencing “Climate Change” | FL, State | Government Censorship | Climate | Florida Governor Rick Scott banned state employees from using the terms “climate change” and “global warming” in official correspondence. |
|
2017-11 | NPS Staff Reprimanded for Climate Change Tweet | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | The Secretary of the Interior reprimanded the head of Joshua Tree National Park after climate change-related tweets were posted from the park’s account. |
|
2017-11 | Release of Pesticide Study Blocked by DOI | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship, Research Hindrance | Other | Political appointees at the Department of the Interior (DOI) blocked release of a report, examining the impact of three widely used pesticides on endangered and threatened species. The report, which had been prepared by scientists at DOI’s Fish and Wildlife Service, found that use of the pesticides would threaten the continued existence of thousands of species. |
|
2017-10-30 | EPA Scientists’ Speaking Engagements Cancelled | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | EPA cancelled talks by 3 scientists who were scheduled to discuss climate change at a conference on the state of the Narragansett Bay. |
|
2017-10-25 | References to “Climate Change” Removed from DOI Strategic Plan | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | The Department of the Interior (DOI) published a new five-year strategic plan which omitted any reference to “climate change.” The previous version of the plan had included a detailed discussion of the likely impacts of climate change on DOI’s activities and required the department to take steps to mitigate those impacts. |
|
2017-10 | References to “Climate Change” Removed from EPA’s International Website | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate, Other | Between October and December 2017, EPA made various changes to its International Cooperation website, including removing information about climate change. |
|
2017-10 | Forest Service Scientist Prevented from Attending Conference | Federal, USDA | Government Censorship | Climate | A U.S. Forest Service scientist was denied approval to travel to an international fire conference where he was scheduled to speak on severe fire weather conditions and climate change. |
|
2017-10 | EPA Website Relaunched Without Climate Change Materials | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | Multiple links to materials aimed at helping local government officials adapt to climate change were removed from EPA’s website. |
|
2017-09 | Climate Science Page Removed from EPA Website | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | A section on climate science was deleted from the website of EPA’s “SmartWay” program and other sections were amended to remove references to “climate change” and related terms. |
|
2017-09 | Database of Science-Based Programs Suspended by HHS | Federal, HHS | Government Censorship | Other | HHS suspended the National Registry of Evidence-based Programs and Practices which lists addiction and mental health programs that have been independently assessed and deemed scientifically sound. |
|
2017-08-31 | CDC Employees Prevented from Speaking to Reporters | Federal, HHS | Government Censorship | Other | Employees at the Centers for Disease Control were instructed not to speak with any member of the news media, regardless of the nature of their inquiry, without the approval of the communications office. |
|
2017-08-17 | Climate Change Omitted from White House’s List of FY2019 R&D Priorities | Federal, White House | Budget Cuts, Government Censorship | Climate | The White House Office of Management and Budget and Office of Science and Technology Policy jointly released a memorandum outlining the Trump administration’s research and development priorities. Unlike previous versions, issued during the Obama administration, the memorandum does not list climate change as a priority area. |
|
2017-08 | U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Official Pressured to Reverse Environmental Permit Decision | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship, Self-Censorship | Climate, Other | A former U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service official revealed that, while employed as a field supervisor in Arizona, he was pressured by the Trump Administration’s U.S. Department of the Interior to reverse his decision regarding a biological assessment of a proposed massive housing development project. |
|
2017-07-27 | Climate Change Information Removed from USDA Website | Federal, USDA | Government Censorship | Climate | Information on climate change mitigation and adaptation was removed, and then returned, to USDA’s “Climate Hubs” website. |
|
2017-07 | References to “Climate Change” Removed from NIH Website | Federal, HHS | Government Censorship | Climate | References to “climate change” and links to climate-related documents, including an educational fact sheet on climate change and human health, were removed from the National Environmental Health Sciences website. |
|
2017-07 | NPS Scientist Excluded from Tour | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | DOI prevented the Superintendent of Glacier National Park, a noted climate change expert, from participating in Mark Zuckerberg’s tour of the park. |
|
2017-05-18 | “Climate Change” References Removed from USGS Press Release | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | DOI amended the press release for a paper on sea level rise to remove a sentence identifying climate change as its cause. |
|
2017-05 | DOI Scientists Work Criticized by Political Appointees | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | Political appointees at DOI criticized a U.S Geological Survey press release, which described climate change as “dramatically” reducing the size of glaciers. One official described the statement as a “perfect example of [scientists] going outside their wheelhouse” and another indicated that “we need to watch for inflammatory [language] in their press releases.” |
|
2017-05 | “Climate Change” References Removed from FHWA Website | DOT, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | References to “climate change” on the FHWA’s website and were replaced with alternate terms such as “resiliency” and “sustainability.” |
|
2017-05 | Climate Change Information Buried on EPA Website | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | EPA buried a webpage intended to educate school children about climate change, removing a link to the page from an archived version of its website. |
|
2017-05 | References to “Clean Energy” Removed from DOE Website | DOE, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | DOE’s “Clean Energy Investment Center” was renamed the “Energy Investor Center” and all references to “clean energy” were removed from its website. |
|
2017-05 | Climate Change Page Removed from BLM Website | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | A page describing efforts to address climate change, and providing links to DOI and other federal resources on climate change and renewable energy, was removed from the Bureau of Land Management’s website. |
|
2017-05 | Word “Climate” Removed from BIA Program Name | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | The “Tribal Climate Resilience Program” was renamed the “Tribal Resilience Program” and all references to “climate” and “climate change” were removed from its website. |
|
2017-05 | EPA Advisory Board Chair Pressured to Change Congressional Testimony | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | The chair of EPA’s Board of Scientific Counselors was pressured to change her testimony before Congress to downplay the Trump administration’s decision not to reappoint half of the board’s members. |
|
2017-04-28 | EPA Climate Change Website Removed | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | EPA’s climate change website was removed and replaced with a message indicating that it is being updated to reflect the agency’s priorities under President Trump. |
|
2017-04-19 | Climate Change Information Removed from DOI Website | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | DOI’s main climate change webpage was revised to omit various references to the adverse effects of climate change and a detailed discussion of DOI’s climate change priorities. |
|
2017-04 | EPA Scientist’s Participation in Public Events Restricted | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | An EPA scientist was warned not to speak on climate change at public-facing events or to have such events approved by headquarters in advance. |
|
2017-04 | Benefits of Renewable Energy Downplayed by DOE | DOE, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | DOE changed its website to remove references to renewable energy as a low-emission alternative to fossil fuels and focus solely on renewable energy’s potential to create jobs. |
|
2017-04 | DOE Scientists Prevented from Attending Conference | DOE, Federal | Government Censorship | Other | Up to 27 DOE scientists were told they could not attend the 2017 International Atomic Energy Agency conference. |
|
2017-04 | Oil and Gas Production Risks Downplayed on GAO Website | Federal, GAO | Government Censorship | Climate, Other | A GOA website on managing federal oil and gas resources was edited to remove content on the environmental and public health risks of shale oil and gas production. |
|
2017-04 | Release of Climate Change Study Blocked by Amtrak | Amtrak, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | Amtrak blocked release of a study, titled “Amtrak NEC Climate Change Vulnerability Assessment,” detailing the impact of climate change on a 10-mile stretch of the Northeast Corridor Route connecting Boston to Washington D.C. A redacted version of the study was released, pursuant to a Freedom of Information Act request, in November 2018. |
|
2017-04 | Climate Change Resources Removed from DOE Website | DOE, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | Links to various climate change resources, including the National Climate Assessment, were removed from the DOE’s main climate change website. |
|
2017-03-07 | Word “Science” Removed from EPA Science Office Website | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship | Other | References to EPA’s Office of Science and Technology policy developing “science-based standards” were changed to read “economically and technologically achievable standards.” |
|
2017-03 | WSU Researcher Investigated by Washington Legislators | State, WA | Government Censorship, Research Hindrance | Other | Washington State Representative Joel Kretz and State Senator Mark Schoesler filed a scientific misconduct complaint against a Washington State University (WSU) professor in relation to a 2014 study he had conducted on wolf predation. Representative Kretz had previously sought to discredit the study, including by having the professor fired by WSU. |
|
2017-02-09 | EPA Staff Prevented from Attending Climate Conference | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | Half of the 34 EPA staffers scheduled to attend the Alaska Forum on the Environment were told they could no longer attend the event. |
|
2017-02-08 | Wisconsin Natural Resources Magazine Slated for Closure | State, WI | Budget Cuts, Government Censorship | Climate, Other | In his budget proposal for 2017-19, Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker recommended that the state Department of Natural Resources cease publishing a bimonthly magazine, providing information on environmental issues. Critics say the move is intended to “create a vacuum and black out information on very important environmental issues” such as climate change. |
|
2017-02-03 | EPA Employees Warned About Speaking Publicly | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate, Other | EPA staff received an email warning them that, while they are free to speak publicly, doing so presents risks. |
|
2017-02 | References to “Climate Change” Removed from Idaho Science Education Standards | ID, State | Government Censorship, Interference with Education | Climate | The Idaho House of Representatives Education Committee voted to remove references to “climate change” from draft science education standards. |
|
2017-02 | Animal Welfare Documents Removed from USDA Website | Federal, USDA | Government Censorship | Other | Thousands of documents detailing animal welfare violations were removed from USDA’s website after being made publicly available for decades. |
|
2017-02 | Impact of Fossil Fuels Downplayed by DOI | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate | DOI removed several references to the adverse effects of fossil fuels and the need to develop cleaner renewable energy technologies from its energy website. |
|
2017-01-25 | EPA Scientists’ Research Subject to Review Before Publication | EPA, Federal | Government Censorship, Research Hindrance | Climate, Other | The head of communications for the EPA transition team indicated that agency scientists would be required to have their research reviewed before publication. |
|
2017-01-21 | Arctic Strategy Removed from White House Website | Federal, White House | Government Censorship | Climate | The White House deleted links to the U.S. National Strategy for the Arctic and related documents from its website. |
|
2017-01-20 | “Climate Change” References Removed from White House Website | Federal, White House | Government Censorship | Climate | The White House website was re-launched with all references to “climate change” removed. |
|
2017-01 | Climate Change Pages Removed from State Department Website | Federal, State Department | Government Censorship | Climate | The State Department removed various pages mentioning climate change from its website, including a page providing links to the department’s 2010, 2014, and 2016 Climate Action Reports. |
|
2017-01 | Public Communication by DOI Staff Restricted | DOI, Federal | Government Censorship | Climate, Other | The Trump transition team instructed DOI staff not to send out press releases, post on social media or blogs, or update websites and to consult with senior officials before speaking to the media. |
|
2017-01 | Public Communication by HHS Staff Restricted | Federal, HHS | Government Censorship | Other | The Trump transition team instructed HHS staff not to send out press releases, post on social media or blogs, or update websites and to consult with senior officials before speaking to the media. |
|
2017-01 | Public Communication by USDA Staff Restricted | Federal, USDA | Government Censorship | Climate, Other | The Trump transition team instructed USDA staff not to send out press releases, post on social media or blogs, or update websites and to consult with senior officials before speaking to the media. |
|
2017 | Materials Removed from HHS Website | Federal, HHS | Government Censorship | Other | Between June and December 2017, various content was removed from the website of HHS’s Office of Women’s Health, including pages discussing breast cancer and lesbian and bisexual health. |
|
2016-12 | References to “Climate Change” Removed from Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources’ Website | State, WI | Government Censorship | Climate | The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources’ website was changed to downplay the scientific consensus on climate change. A section describing “[h]uman activities . . . [as] the main cause” of climate change was removed and replaced with a statement that the “reasons for [climate] change . . . are being debated.” Another section discussing the likely adverse effects of climate change was also removed and replace with a statement that possible effects “are being debated.” |
|
2016-11 | References to “Climate Change” Removed from CDC Website | Federal, HHS | Government Censorship, Self-Censorship | Climate | In late 2016, following the presidential election, several references to “climate change” were removed from the website of the CDC’s National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. |